The line on weekends is real. The pancakes at the front of that line are not worth it. The sweet potato pancake has a reputation that predates the current kitchen's ability to consistently justify it. The broader menu is diner food that has been coasting on nostalgia for longer than most of its customers have been alive.
Nashville has better breakfast within walking distance of wherever you're standing. The only reason to wait in the Pancake Pantry line is if someone you love insists on it, in which case you accept your fate and order the sweet potato pancake and nothing else.
Sixty years of reputation doing the work of a kitchen that stopped earning it.
Pancake Pantry has been making pancakes in Hillsboro Village since 1961 and its reputation was built before the current kitchen could consistently justify it. Long lines on weekends. The sweet potato pancake is the one item that has earned its reputation. Everything else is diner food coasting on sixty years of nostalgia.