Five Points Pizza has been doing New York-style pizza in East Nashville since 2011 and has earned its reputation the right way — by being consistently excellent for long enough that people stopped questioning it. The slices are large, properly made, and available by the slice or by the pie. The dough is developed correctly. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is honest.
The lunch special is one of the better value propositions in Nashville — two slices and a drink for a price that makes the more expensive options feel embarrassing. The happy hour slice-and-beer is equally considered.
Five Points Pizza is the standard-setter for Nashville pizza — proper dough, quality toppings, and the kind of consistency that turns first-timers into regulars. This is just genuinely great pizza.
Five Points Pizza has been doing New York-style pizza in East Nashville since 2011 and has earned its reputation by being consistently excellent without fuss. Large slices, properly developed dough, quality toppings, available by the slice or the pie. The lunch special is one of the better deals in the city. A neighborhood anchor that earns its place.